Well right in this moment, there is nobody seriously proposing to paint-bomb a billboard, but at least in this case we have previous experience from someone vandalizing a Clive Palmer billboard with XR slogans and a logo during the election season last year - it went down very well. In any case, I donât believe that taking feedback and trying to integrate concerns is âtrouble with planning things this wayâ. If there are people with serious concerns about targeting billboards, we should try to integrate those concerns as much as possible within the DNA and Pâs and Vâs of XR. If we have a group gearing up to vandalize billboards, we should take feedback on that, and do our best to act in accordance with an approach that integrates the feedback.
In the case of blood of our children actions there is a significant amount of pushback coming from within the movement to say that now is not a good time for this action. This hinges actually on several factors:
- Itâs been very contentious with indigenous groups with whom we are trying to build solidarity. While weâve so far failed to integrate much indigenous presence within the movement, an action that provokes indigenous people is not going to be helpful to doing so. Dealing with the social fallout that could follow this is probably not worth it at this time, especially when weâve seen so many organizing rebels âdeactivatedâ in the last few months. This should be a time when weâre trying to reactivate rebels.
- Actions involving blood are very likely to evoke the pandemic, even if we have a big olâ âclimate emergencyâ banner in the middle of every shot. This action, however, is not about the pandemic. UK M&M guidelines âBe sensitive to our shared global experiences and support the expanded space to reflect upon what we have learned.â
These main points push me to think that Blood of our Children should be kept on the shelf until a bit later on. Iâm also thinking that a big second wave in Australia, while possible, is not highly likely in the next couple of months, and so thereâs no urgency to carry out this action in particular, when we have so many other options in development. The public health response seems to have it under control. Case numbers are going down in the midst of a vigilant surveillance system.